From the essay shelf

Nothing Comes and Goes

For the first two years I read everything I could find about shifting, and I read it the way a person reads about a country they have been told they come from and cannot remember. Other people wrote about the wolf rising in them at dusk. They wrote about an hour in which words fell away, and about coming back afterward, a little dazed, to the human business of the evening. They wrote well, and I believed every line of it.

None of it had ever happened to me. I am an otter. I have been one for as long as I have been anything, and in thirty-odd years the otter has never once come forward, because it has never once been anywhere else.

The thing I thought was missing

I took this, at first, for a deficiency. Shifts were plainly the center of the matter. They were what the guides explained, what newcomers asked about, what people recorded in their journals. I had a journal too. It said things like "Tuesday. Nothing." and "Saturday. Went swimming. Nothing." After some months I stopped keeping it, because a notebook that says "nothing" on every page begins to look like an argument.

I tried to bring a shift on. I am a little embarrassed to say so. I sat by the river in the evenings with the right music in my ears and waited for something to arrive. The river was lovely. Nothing arrived. I concluded, with the thoroughness of the young, that I was probably not a therian at all, only a man who was very fond of otters and had been fooling himself.

The difficulty with that conclusion was that it changed nothing. I went on being exactly what I had been. I still could not walk past water without wanting to be in it. I still handled everything, turned it over, tested it, and was scolded for fidgeting at the age of thirty as I had been at eight. I still wanted to play, which is not a dignified thing to admit as an adult, and I do not mean games with rules. I mean that a wet bank is to me an invitation, and always has been.

Always on

What I had missed is easy to say and took me a long time to see. I had been looking for an event, and there was no event to find because there was no "before" for it to stand against. A person who shifts has a human hour and an animal hour and can hold one up to the other. I have only the one hour. It is otter-and-man, the whole of it, all day, and it has never been otherwise.

Someone who is the same thing all the time does not notice being it. You do not feel your own accent. I had been waiting to feel like an otter, and the reason I never did was that I had never, for comparison, felt like anything else.

When I at last found the word contherian and read the two paragraphs that went with it, I laughed out loud, alone in my kitchen. Somebody had already been through all this, long before me, and had been good enough to leave a note.

An ordinary Tuesday

People sometimes ask what it is like, and I find the question hard, in the way it would be hard to say what it is like to be right-handed. But here is a Tuesday.

I wake quickly and all at once. I am hungry at once too, and I think about breakfast with an interest that my wife finds comic. I walk to work along the canal and not along the road, which adds eleven minutes, and I have never seriously considered the road. I look at the water the whole way. I am not looking for anything. It is simply where my eyes go.

At work I am, by all accounts, good company and slightly tiring. I do my thinking with something in my hands. I am quick, I am curious, I am easily bored, and I get through a great deal in short bursts with idleness between. If a colleague is low I will find some small silly thing to do about it. In meetings I sit near the door, and I could not tell you how I chose the seat.

None of that is a shift. Nothing rose and nothing ebbed. If you had stopped me at any moment and asked "are you more otter just now, or less?" I would not have understood the question.

I do have sharper moments. A sudden noise behind me, a child stepping toward the road, a pan slipping off the stove: for a second or two everything in me comes to a point and the body moves before I have thought. But I do not feel more of an animal then. I feel like the same animal, startled. I would guess that an otter on a riverbank has such moments too, and does not come out of them thinking that it was particularly otter-like just now.

Envy, and the end of it

I will admit that I envied the shifters for a while. Their accounts had weather in them. Mine was a flat calm. It is hard to write a stirring essay about a state that does not change, and I felt that I had been handed the plain version of something other people had in color.

What ended the envy was getting to know some of them. One friend, a lynx, told me that her shifts are the best hours of her week and also that the hours between can feel like exile. She has the animal vividly, and then she has it taken away, and then she waits. I had never thought of it from that side. I have nothing so vivid as she has. I also have nothing to wait for and nothing to miss. The otter does not visit. It lives here.

She said that she sometimes envied that. I think we were both a little surprised. It seems to be an arrangement in which each kind suspects the other of having the real thing, when both have it, in different coin.

For anyone who doubts on this account

I still meet people, mostly young and newly arrived, who have decided they cannot be therians because they do not shift. They have read what I read. They have sat by their own rivers. Often they have a list of things about themselves a page long, every item of which has been true since they were small, and they have set the whole list aside because one thing is not on it.

If that is you, I would ask you to look at the list again and not at the gap. Shifting is one of the ways this identity makes itself felt. It is the way that was written about first, because it gives a writer something to describe. It was never the definition. The library's page on contherians and suntherians sets out the words, and you may find, as I did, that someone has left you a note.

I did go back to the journal in the end. I keep it differently now. I do not write "nothing." I write what there was: "Canal low. Two moorhens. Could not sit still in the afternoon." It is a record of an otter's days, and there is an entry for every one of them.

Pieces in the stacks are written under pen names. Personal pieces are composite accounts that gather experiences commonly described by therians and otherkin, and are offered as illustration, not as testimony about any one person. See the editorial principles.

Shelved under Essays Shifting

This page was last tended on .