The Therian Grove

Contherians, Suntherians and Vacillants

Not every therian shifts. For some the animal is simply always there, at one level or within a narrow range. Three words describe this steadier kind of experience, and they are often confused with one another.

A therianthropy without shifts

The earliest descriptions of therianthropy were written by people who shifted strongly, and for some years shifting was treated as the center of the subject. A person was human most of the time and, now and then, markedly more animal. There was no special name for this pattern, and there still is not one in common use. "Shifting therian" is sometimes written, but it is a description and not a term of its own.

Then others spoke up who recognized everything in the accounts except the shifts. They were animals, as surely as anyone. Nothing in them came and went. The words on this page were coined, one after another, to make room for them.

Contherian: one steady state

A contherian experiences human and animal as a single constant blend. The word dates from the late 1990s.

Contherians often say that the simplest way to picture it is as a shift that never switches off, though most add at once that it does not feel like a shift, because there is nothing to compare it with. There was never a time when the animal was further away. One long-standing description runs roughly like this: the person is in a steady state of being their animal; a sudden noise or a difficult moment may sharpen the instincts for a while, as it would in any creature; but they do not at any point feel more animal or less.

That last distinction matters. A contherian's alertness, mood and energy rise and fall like anyone's. What does not rise and fall is the sense of what they are.

How the blend is weighted varies from person to person. Some contherians feel mostly human with an animal grain running through everything. Some feel about equally both. Some do not feel human at all in any inward respect, while living a perfectly ordinary human life, and may also describe themselves as holotheres. Otherkin with the same steady pattern sometimes use conkin.

Suntherian: a blend that drifts

A suntherian is also always both, and also has no shifts in the usual sense. The difference is that the blend moves. Over hours or days it leans a little toward the animal, then a little toward the human, smoothly, as a mood might. It never tips over into a separate state, and there is no moment at which a shift could be said to begin or end.

The word was coined in the 2000s by one person, to describe their own experience. They found that contherian did not allow for the natural variation they felt, and that the language of shifting overstated it. Others recognized the pattern and took the word up.

That origin explains a good deal of later confusion. A term made to fit one person's account has been stretched in several directions by those who borrowed it. It is often used as a plain synonym for contherian, and some popular lists define the two the wrong way around. Where precision matters, it is better to describe the experience in a sentence than to rely on either word being understood.

Vacillant: the older word

Vacillant comes from the early otherkin and therian communities, and described much the same thing as suntherian before that word existed: a person always somewhere between human and nonhuman, whose position sways. It had nearly fallen out of use by the 2010s and is met mostly in older essays.

It has had a small revival among younger therians, some of whom use "vacillant therian" in a slightly different sense: for someone who does have mental shifts, but gentle and gradual ones, more "I feel rather more animal just now" than a clear change of state. Whether that is a third pattern or simply suntherian described from another side is a matter on which people differ. The library records both senses and takes no side.

The three side by side

WordAlways both?Does the balance move?Distinct shifts?
Therian who shiftsNot necessarily felt soYes, between recognizable statesYes
ContherianYesNoNo
SuntherianYesYes, slowly and within a narrow rangeNo
VacillantYesYes; in older use the same as suntherianNo, or only very gentle ones in some newer use

These are points along a continuum, and the lines between them are not sharp. Someone who cannot decide whether they are a suntherian or a contherian with good days and bad days has not failed to understand the terms. They have found the place where the terms run out.

What about phantom limbs

The words on this page were coined with mental shifts in mind. Many contherians and suntherians do feel phantom limbs. Some feel them constantly, as a settled part of the body's inner map. Others notice them come and go while the sense of self stays level. Neither contradicts the label. A contherian with a phantom tail on some days and not on others is describing a change in sensation, not a change in what they are.

Born steady, or settled over time

Some people have been contherian for as long as they can remember. Others began with vivid shifts in their teens and found, over ten or twenty years, that the shifts softened and at last merged into a level background. The community calls that settling integration.

The two roads arrive at much the same place, and people who have traveled the second often adopt the word contherian once they are there. Some keep a distinction, reserving contherian for those who never shifted. Usage is not settled, and nobody is wrong.

The reverse also happens, more rarely. A person who has been level for years may meet a hard season, a bereavement or a move to a very different place, and find shifts returning for a while. That does not undo anything either.

Common doubts

  • "If I never shift, how do I know?" In the same way anyone knows: by the lasting, involuntary sense of being a particular animal, in reflex, attention and body sense, traced back through the years. Shifts are one kind of evidence among several, and plenty of therians have managed without them. The page on awakening and questioning lists what tends to be true of therians, and shifting is not on the list.
  • "Is it less real?" No. The first contherians had to argue this, and the argument was settled in their favor long ago.
  • "Is contherian the more advanced state?" No again. Integration is common and usually welcome, but it is not a rank, and a therian who shifts vividly at sixty has not fallen behind.
  • "Should I try to shift?" There is no need. A person may invite the animal nearer if they wish, as the page on voluntary and involuntary shifts describes, but a contherian who feels no lack is missing nothing.

The essay Nothing Comes and Goes describes a contherian's ordinary day from the inside.

Shelved under Therianthropy Definitions

This page was last tended on .