The Therian Grove

Cladotherians

Some therians search for a species and find instead that the whole branch is theirs: bear, not one kind of bear. The word for this is cladotherian, and it is among the less familiar terms in the vocabulary.

What the word means

A cladotherian is a therian whose theriotype is not a single species and not a set of separate animals, but one whole group of related animals taken together. Such a person does not feel like a brown bear, or like a brown bear and a polar bear side by side. They feel like bear: whatever it is that all bears share.

The experience, cladotherianthropy, is not common, and many therians of long standing have never met anyone who uses the word. It is not new or doubtful on that account. It has been part of the community's vocabulary for more than twenty years, and it appears in most lists of terms even when little is said about it beyond a line of definition. This page tries to say a little more.

A branch on the tree

The word joins two Greek roots: klados, a branch, and therion, a wild animal. The first was chosen with biology in mind. In the study of how living things are related, a clade is one ancestor together with all of its descendants. Drawn out on paper, those relationships look like a tree, and a clade is a single branch of it with every twig it carries.

The choice was a careful one. It says that what a cladotherian identifies as is a real kinship among animals, a line of descent, and not a loose collection of animals that happen to appeal.

The word was in use on one of the early therian forums by 2003, and is credited to a member there whose own theriotype was reptiles as a whole. It may well be somewhat older, since records of those years are incomplete. The page on how the words changed places it among the other terms coined in that period by people who did not see themselves in the first descriptions of therianthropy.

How wide a branch

Biologists sort animals into ranks, each wider than the last. A cladotherian's branch may sit at any of them, though some are far commoner than others. Bears make a convenient example.

RankThe branchWhat it takes in
SpeciesThe brown bearOne animal. This is an ordinary theriotype, and no special word is needed.
GenusThe typical bearsThe brown bear, the polar bear, and the American and Asiatic black bears.
FamilyAll bearsThose four, with the sun bear, the sloth bear, the spectacled bear, the giant panda, and extinct kin such as the short-faced bears.
OrderThe carnivoresBears together with dogs, cats, weasels, seals, hyenas and many more.

Most cladotherians describe a branch at the level of a genus or a family: the foxes, the cat family, the deer, the falcons. Wider branches, an order or a whole class such as reptiles or birds, are also claimed, and these are the cases that have drawn most discussion. The wider the branch, the less its members have in common, and the harder it becomes to say what exactly is being recognized. The word itself sets no limit. A person using it at great breadth should expect to be asked, kindly, what the experience is like.

A small difficulty shows why the word is best defined by kinship and not by rank. Some genera contain only one living species. A person whose theriotype is that animal is not made a cladotherian by a quirk of classification. The useful test is whether the identity really does take in a group of related animals, not which rung of the ladder it happens to sit on.

One theriotype, not several

The word is most often confused with polytherian, and the difference is worth stating carefully.

AspectCladotherianPolytherian
How many theriotypesOne, broad in scopeTwo or more, each distinct
How they relateA single branch of kindred animalsMay be unrelated, such as rat, magpie and salmon
What is feltWhat the whole group sharesEach animal in its own right
ExampleAll elephants, living and extinctA tiger, a lion and a leopard, felt separately

The last row is the instructive one. Tiger, lion and leopard all belong to the same genus of great cats. A person who is each of those three is a polytherian whose theriotypes happen to be cousins. They would be a cladotherian of that genus only if the identity took in the whole of it, jaguar and snow leopard included, as a single thing.

The two are not exclusive. A person may be a cladotherian of the deer family and also, quite separately, a raven. That person is both. The page on polytherians covers the other side of the comparison.

Three concerns, fairly put

The term has had its critics within the community, and their concerns are reasonable ones. Each has a fair answer.

  • That it is a name for not having finished. A person who knows they are some kind of cat and has not yet worked out which is a therian still searching. A cladotherian has searched, often for years, and concluded that the family is the answer. From outside the two look alike. From inside they are different, and the honest course is simply to say which one is the case. "I am still looking" is a perfectly good sentence.
  • That it is used for a handful of relatives. Someone who is a red fox and a gray wolf, and then finds a jackal as well, has three canine theriotypes. That does not make them a cladotherian of the whole dog family unless the dhole, the bush dog and the African wild dog belong to the identity too. A few species within a group is polytherianthropy.
  • That at great width it becomes something else. A person who shifts toward a wide and changing range of animals, with no pattern of kinship among them, is not describing a clade. Older writing sometimes used the word polymorph for a therian with no settled form at all. Whatever one makes of that term, it marks a real distinction.

A fourth view is sometimes heard: that few therians can truly tell one subspecies of wolf from another in themselves, and that a good many are therefore cladotherians without knowing it. There may be something in that. It is also a reminder that these words are tools for description, and that a tool is used when it helps.

How it is described from within

Accounts by cladotherians tend to share a shape. The person begins by looking for a species, as most therians do. They read about one animal and recognize themselves. They read about its cousin and recognize themselves again, just as strongly. This continues. At some point the list of candidates becomes absurd, and the person understands that the list was never a list. It was one thing seen from several sides.

What they then describe is usually a body and a manner common to the group. A deer cladotherian may speak of the long ears, the wide watchfulness and the readiness to run, without being able to say whether the antlers are a roe's or an elk's, and without feeling that the question has an answer. Shifts and dreams may wear the face of one species on one day and another the next, while the animal underneath stays the same.

The essay Every Deer I Met in the stacks gives one such account in a personal voice.

If you think this may be you

  • Finish looking first. Study the species within the group one at a time, as the page on theriotypes describes. If one of them turns out to fit better than the rest, that is your answer.
  • Look for what does not fit. A true clade identity is at home with every member of the group, the unglamorous ones included. If you are a "feline" who feels nothing for the small spotted cats, look again.
  • Learn the family tree. Kinship among animals is often not what it appears. Hyenas are nearer to cats than to dogs, and the red panda is not a bear. Know which branch you are actually on.
  • Say it plainly. "My theriotype is foxes in general" tells a listener more than the technical word does, and may be all that is needed.
  • Hold it loosely. Some people rest at the family for a few years and then find a species after all. Others never do. Neither outcome makes the earlier answer a mistake.

The page on kinds of therian sets this word among its neighbors, and reminds the reader that plain "therian" is always enough.

Shelved under Therianthropy Definitions

This page was last tended on .