From the essay shelf

Every Deer I Met

I knew I was a deer before I knew there was a word for people who know such things. That part was never in question. I had the ears, long and turning. I had the habit of standing quite still at the edge of a room until I had found the doors. I had hooves, or rather I had the absence of them, a feeling at the ends of my legs that the ground ought to meet me on two neat points and did not.

What I did not have was a species. For six years I looked for one, and this is an account of how the looking ended.

The first one

I began where most people in my part of the world would begin, with the roe deer, because they were the deer I could go and see. They came down to the field behind the houses at dusk, three or four together, small and russet and neat. I watched them every evening for a summer. I learned the bark they give when alarmed, and the way a doe will stamp one forefoot at something she mistrusts.

It fit. I wrote in my notebook, with a good deal of satisfaction, "roe deer," and underlined it.

And the second

That winter I read a long book about red deer on a northern hillside, written by a man who had watched one herd for most of his life. I meant it as background. By the third chapter I had stopped being able to read it as background. The hinds moving up the hill in a line behind an old leader, the months lived among females and young, the long patience of it. I knew that from inside, as plainly as I knew the roe in the field.

So I crossed out "roe deer" and wrote "red deer," less firmly.

You can guess the rest. Fallow deer in a park, palmate antlers and spotted flanks, and the same jolt. Reindeer in a film about the far north, both sexes antlered, walking into the wind for a thousand miles, and the same. A little muntjac, hardly bigger than a dog, barking in a wood. Moose in the birch swamps, enormous and solitary and odd, nothing like the roe at all, and I recognized them too.

My notebook from those years is not a dignified document. It has six species in it, each written with conviction and each crossed out for the next. By the end I was writing them in pencil.

What I was afraid of

I had read the usual warnings, and they are good ones. A list of theriotypes that grows every few months is a sign of enthusiasm more often than of discovery. I did not want to be someone who collected animals. I especially did not want to be someone who said she was six kinds of deer.

So I tried to be strict. I tried ranking them. I tried to work out which one my phantom antlers belonged to, and found that the antlers would not settle either: some days a simple fork, some days so wide that I had to tilt my head to get through doorways, and for a good part of every year nothing at all, which is correct for nearly all of them. I tried deciding by landscape and discovered that I am at home on a hill, in a wood, at the edge of a field and in a swamp, provided that there is cover within a short run.

What I did not find, in all that sorting, was a single thing that divided the six. Every time I looked for the difference, I found the likeness. The ears. The watchfulness. The way the whole body listens. The fawn left lying still in the long grass, which I have known all my life as a memory of something that never happened to me. The cast antlers and the bare months. The sudden decision to be elsewhere.

It was a deer. It had been a deer the whole time. I had been walking round one animal and describing it from six sides.

The word

I found the word cladotherian in a list of terms, with one line of definition beside it, and at first I did not trust it. It looked like exactly the kind of word a person reaches for to avoid making up her mind.

That is the fair objection, and I have had it put to me since. Are you sure you have not simply failed to narrow it down? I can only say what the difference is like from inside. When I was undecided between roe and red, there was a question in me, and it itched. Now there is no question. Nothing is waiting to be settled. If you ask me which deer I am, I do not feel that I lack the answer. I feel that the question is slightly the wrong shape, as it would be if you asked which wave was the sea.

I also know where it stops, and that seems to me important. I am not hoofed animals in general. Horses are strangers to me, and so are goats and cattle, fond as I am of them. I am not an antelope, though I can see why someone might think the gap small. The feeling runs exactly as far as the deer family runs and then it ends, as cleanly as a fence line. That is what persuaded me that I was looking at something real. A thing I had made up would not have kept such tidy borders.

Whether it is laziness

I have asked myself that, and I think the honest answer is: a little, at first, and then not. There was a month near the end when I was simply tired of looking and would have accepted any conclusion that let me stop. If I had taken the word then, it would have been laziness.

I did not take it then. I went back and read about each of the six again, slowly, looking for the one I had been unfair to. I spent a spring watching the roe with the particular aim of finding out whether they were, after all, the whole answer. They were not. They were a part of it, and so was each of the others, and what was left when I took any one of them away was still a deer.

So I would say this to anyone standing where I stood. Do the work first. Look at each animal properly and give it the chance to be the one. If one of them is, you will know, and you will have a species, and that is a fine thing to have. But if you have looked honestly and the family is what remains, do not go on punishing yourself for an answer that is not coming. Some of us are a branch and not a leaf.

How it is now

I use the long word very seldom. To the few people who know, I say that I am a deer, and if they ask what kind I say "all of them, more or less," and most people find that easier to understand than I expected.

The roe still come down to the field at dusk. I still go and watch them, and I am glad I began with them. I think of them now as the cousins who happen to live nearest. When I travel I look for whatever deer the country has, and I have not yet met one I did not know. I have a list in the back of the notebook of the ones I have seen and the ones I hope to. It is the only list of deer I keep, and nothing on it is crossed out.

Pieces in the stacks are written under pen names. Personal pieces are composite accounts that gather experiences commonly described by therians and otherkin, and are offered as illustration, not as testimony about any one person. See the editorial principles.

Shelved under Essays Theriotypes

This page was last tended on .