The Wolf Walk

Folklore or Film? Werewolf Beliefs Sorted

Most of what people now know about werewolves was settled in the last hundred years. This page goes through the familiar ideas one at a time and says, as plainly as the evidence allows, which are old, which are scattered and which are new.

Why sort them

There is nothing wrong with a new idea. The werewolf of film and fiction is a fine invention, and the page on the werewolf in story follows how it was made. The trouble comes only when recent inventions are passed off as ancient lore, because then the real folklore, which is stranger and more various, is hidden behind them.

Three labels are used below. Old means widely recorded in folklore before the twentieth century. Scattered means found here and there in older sources, but never as a general rule. Modern means that the idea was established by novels, magazines and films. Folklore is untidy, and an exception can be found to almost any statement about it.

Becoming a werewolf

A bite passes it on

Modern. In older belief a person became a werewolf by putting on a skin or a belt, by a salve, by a curse, or by the circumstances of their birth. The bite that infects belongs to films of the 1930s and 1940s. A rare exception shows how different the old idea was: a Russian belief held that a sorcerer in wolf form, at certain seasons, could turn a person into a wolf for seven years by biting them, and that the victim could be rid of the shape by biting someone else. That is a spell handed on, not an infection.

It is a disease

Modern. The old werewolf was under a curse, a penance or an enchantment, or had chosen the shape by sorcery. Talk of a virus, a strain or a bloodline is the vocabulary of twentieth-century fiction. Physicians did speak of lycanthropy as an illness, but they meant a sickness of the mind in which no change took place.

A belt or a skin does it

Old. This is the commonest belief of all, from the Norse sagas to the German trial records, and it is set out under signs, causes and cures.

The seventh son is fated to it

Old. The belief is well recorded in Portugal, Spain and South America, and has relatives in the Slavic lands.

The change itself

The full moon brings it on

Scattered, then modern. The moon is mentioned in a few old sources, as one condition among several. The rule that the change comes at every full moon and cannot be resisted was fixed by film. See the werewolf and the full moon, and for the dates the old lore did keep, the werewolf's calendar.

The change is slow and agonizing

Modern. The long transformation scene, with stretching bones and splitting skin, is an achievement of film makeup in the early 1980s. The old stories hardly describe the change at all. A man steps behind a bush, or over a knife, or puts on the belt, and is a wolf.

The werewolf walks upright, half man and half wolf

Modern, with a few old exceptions. The werewolf of folklore was, to look at, a wolf. It might be unusually large, or lack a tail, or have human eyes or cast a human shadow. A creature that is wolf above and human below appears in a few scattered beliefs, but the wolf-man in torn clothes was designed for the camera, which needed an actor's face.

The werewolf remembers nothing

Mostly modern. In the greater part of the old lore the werewolf keeps its human mind. The knight of the medieval lay behaves with courtesy as a wolf. The enchanted werewolves of Slavic tales understand speech, grieve, and try to go home. A few folktales do say that a returned werewolf remembered nothing, but the decent man who wakes in a field with no idea what he has done is the tragic hero of the cinema.

The werewolf is a mindless killer

Scattered. There were man-eating werewolves in folklore, and the trial pamphlets made the most of them. Beside them stood victims, penitents and guardians, among them the Baltic werewolves who called themselves the hounds of God. The single meaning the figure has today is narrower than any it had before.

Weaknesses and cures

Only silver can kill it

Scattered, then modern. A silver button or a blessed coin turns up now and then in older stories as the one shot that will tell against a witch or a charmed animal. As the fixed rule for werewolves, the silver bullet was settled by twentieth-century fiction. The silver bullet in the story of the Beast of Gevaudan, told among the cases on record, was added in retellings long after the event. The folk werewolf could be hurt by an ordinary pitchfork, and the wound stayed on the person, which was how it was found out.

Wolfsbane wards it off

Modern as a rule. The plant is real, its name is old, and it was used to poison wolves. Its fame as the werewolf's herb rests largely on a short verse written for a film of the early 1940s, which has been quoted ever since as if it were traditional. Wolfsbane is dangerously poisonous and should never be handled on the strength of any story.

Call it by name and it is freed

Old. Calling the werewolf by its baptismal name, reproaching it to its face, or drawing a few drops of its blood are among the best recorded remedies in Europe. The old cures aim to restore the person. The modern ones aim to destroy the monster.

A star on the palm marks the next victim

Modern. The five-pointed star seen in the hand is an invention of the same films. The old signs were joined eyebrows, hairy palms and a wound that matched the wolf's.

Werewolves heal at once and cannot die

Modern. Folklore's werewolves were wounded, grew old and were killed like other creatures. A few traditions made them stronger than a common wolf, or proof against a bullet that had not been blessed, but rapid healing and endless life belong to recent fiction.

Company and enemies

Werewolves live in packs ruled by an alpha

Modern. The folk werewolf usually goes alone, or in the company of others under the same spell. In Slavic tales real wolves drive it off because it smells of human. The pack of werewolves with its ranks and its leader comes from fiction of the later twentieth century, and it borrowed its structure from an account of captive wolves that has since been set aside. Wild wolf packs are families, as the page on the real wolf explains, and their so-called alphas are simply the parents.

Werewolves and vampires are ancient enemies

Modern. In the folklore of eastern Europe the two were close kin and sometimes the same being. The feud was invented by films and games. See werewolves and vampires.

There were professional werewolf hunters

Modern. No such calling is recorded. Suspected werewolves were dealt with by courts, by priests, and by villagers who turned out to hunt a wolf.

Werewolves belong to foggy England

Modern. England lost its wolves by about the end of the Middle Ages, and has very little werewolf folklore of its own to show for the centuries since. The moors and gaslit streets were supplied by English and American novels and by films made in California. The legend's old heartlands were France, the German lands, the Baltic and the Slavic countries.

Tales often retold

Tens of thousands were tried as werewolves

Not supported. The figure of thirty thousand trials in France is repeated everywhere and rests on no known records. The documented cases across Europe number in the hundreds at most.

The Beast of Gevaudan was a werewolf

A later reading. The people who lived through those years spoke of a monstrous wolf or an unknown beast. The werewolf was attached to the story afterward.

The kindly wolf-man of the northern isles

Doubtful. A gentle creature with a wolf's head, said to live alone on a Scottish island, to fish from a rock and to leave part of his catch on the windowsills of the poor, is often presented as ancient island lore. He first appears in print in the 1930s, and those who have searched for earlier evidence have not found it. He may have grown from a misread place name. He is a pleasant figure all the same, and a good example of how new a "tradition" can be.

The wolf in the grandmother's bed

Old, in one form. In an oral version of the tale of the little girl and the wolf, recorded in France in the nineteenth century, the creature is called a werewolf. The best-known printed versions have only a wolf.

At a glance

IdeaOld folkloreWhere the modern form comes from
Becoming oneA skin or belt, a salve, a curse, birthThe bite: films of the 1930s and 1940s
TimingFeast days, midwinter, terms of yearsEvery full moon: film
AppearanceA wolf, perhaps large or taillessThe upright wolf-man: film makeup
MindUsually human, and often unhappyNo memory, no control: film tragedy
Ending itThe name, a little blood, the skin burnedSilver alone: magazine fiction and film
CompanyAlone, or with fellow sufferersPacks and alphas: later fiction
EnemiesCourts, priests, frightened neighborsVampires and hunters: films and games

What the sorting shows

The modern werewolf is a tidy creature. It has a cause, a clock, a weakness and a look, and all four were supplied by people who needed a story that an audience could follow in ninety minutes. The werewolf of folklore had none of that tidiness. It could be a sorcerer or a saint's penitent, a wedding guest or a seventh son, a killer or a guardian of the harvest, and its cure was as likely to be a kind word as a weapon.

Something was gained in the tidying, and something was lost. What was lost, mostly, is the person. Old belief nearly always kept in view that there was a human being under the skin who might be called home. The pages on Slavic werewolves and on the medieval romances show that older figure at its fullest.

It is also why the library keeps folklore and identity on separate shelves. Therians are sometimes asked about silver and full moons by people who know only the film werewolf. None of it applies. Therians do not transform, and the essay Folklore Is Not Identity explains the difference.

Shelved under Werewolf lore Folklore

This page was last tended on .