The Sundial Court
The Elven Letters: Before the Forums
Twenty years before the forums, a few people who understood themselves to be elves were writing to one another on paper. The word otherkin, and much of the community's character, came out of that correspondence.
A history that begins on paper
The history of the community opens its timeline in the 1970s with a single entry about small circles of self-described elves. This page fills in that entry. The period is the least documented in the whole story. Its records are letters, newsletters and the recollections of a few people, and the account here keeps to what is generally agreed.
As elsewhere in the library, the people and groups involved are not named. They wrote under elven names of their own choosing, and those names are theirs.
The first circle
At the end of the 1960s or the start of the 1970s, in the western United States, a small household began to speak of themselves as elves. They did not mean that they liked elves, or that they were playing at them. They meant that elf was the truest word they had for what they were, and they set about living accordingly.
They also wrote. Through the 1970s they composed short letters, each signed with elven names and addressed to anyone who might recognize themselves in it, and sent them out by mail. Some were printed in the pagan magazines of the day, which were then among the few places where such a thing could appear. The letters were by turns playful and earnest. They spoke of kinship, of magic, of living lightly and kindly, and they invited replies.
Replies came. Scattered people wrote back to say that they, too, had always felt this way and had never had a word for it. A loose circle formed, held together entirely by mail. By the later 1970s the first household had stopped sending its letters, but the idea had been set loose.
The letters carried on
At the end of that decade another small group of self-described elves traveled to stay with the first household, and lived with them for a time. When they left they took up the writing themselves. Their letters went out for decades afterward, first by mail and much later by other means, and they are the main thread connecting the elven circles of the 1970s to the community that exists now.
It was a culture of correspondence. A letter might be copied by hand and passed to a friend, who passed it to another. Newsletters were typed, duplicated and stapled. People who had never met, and in many cases never would, came to know one another well. A good deal of what later seemed distinctive about the online community, the long personal essay, the chosen name, the habit of patient self-description offered to strangers, was already present in these envelopes.
The star of seven points
The circles took a sign for themselves: a star of seven points drawn in a single unbroken line. They called it the elven star, and it is also known as the faery star. An article explaining it appeared in a pagan newsletter in the summer of 1986, one of the earliest printed discussions of the symbol in this sense.
When the community widened beyond elves, the star went with it. It is now the emblem of the otherkin as a whole, drawn and described on the page of symbols and emblems, and it is the oldest symbol in any of the communities this library describes.
A list for elves, 1990
In 1990 a university student founded an electronic mailing list for, as its description put it, elves and interested observers. It was the first gathering place of its kind on the computer networks, and it did for the elven circles what the mail had done, a great deal faster.
It also changed who was in the room. The list drew people who felt exactly the kind of kinship the elves described, but toward other beings entirely: dragons, creatures of legend, things without convenient names. They were welcome, and they were plainly not elves. A word was wanted for them.
Otherkind and otherkin
In the spring of 1990 a member of the list offered otherkind. By the summer the shorter otherkin was in use beside it, and for a while people used the two as they pleased. The shorter form won. It has been in continuous use ever since, and the pages on otherkin and on how the words changed describe what it came to mean.
The coinage says something about the people who made it. They did not draw a line around the elves and leave the others outside it. They made a larger word and stepped inside it themselves. That habit, of answering a newcomer with a new word and a wider circle, has been repeated at almost every turn of the community's history.
The word had, as it happens, existed before. In the English of the later Middle Ages, otherkin was an adjective meaning "of another kind." Nobody on the mailing list was thinking of that. It is a coincidence, and a pleasing one.
The period in brief
- Around 1970 A small household in the western United States begins to describe itself as elven.
- The 1970s The household sends out letters signed with elven names. Some are printed in pagan magazines. Others who feel the same begin to write back.
- The late 1970s The first household's letters cease. A second group visits, stays, and carries the letter-writing on.
- 1986 An article on the seven-pointed star appears in a pagan newsletter.
- 1990 A mailing list for elves and interested observers is founded. In the spring otherkind is proposed, and by the summer otherkin is in use.
- The early 1990s Public discussion groups for fans of werewolves and of dragons develop followings of people who identify as those beings. The therian community begins.
- 2017 A major historical dictionary of English adds an entry for otherkin.
What came after
The elves' list was soon one meeting place among several. In the early 1990s, public discussion groups made for fans of werewolf stories and for fans of dragons each found that some of their members were not speaking as fans. The werewolf group became the cradle of the therian community, and the dragon group took, as the dragonkin page notes, a similar turn at about the same time. From then on the story is the one told on the main history page and in the forum years.
The word itself went on quietly gaining ground. It appeared now and then in newspaper features, as the page on the communities in the public eye describes. In 2017 a major historical dictionary of the English language gave it an entry, defining an otherkin as a person who identifies as non-human, typically as being wholly or partially an animal or mythical being. A word coined on a small mailing list, to make room for a few guests, had become part of the language.
What the letters left
The elven circles were small, and most of what they wrote has not survived. Their influence is out of proportion to their numbers. They established that a person might say, soberly and without any claim about the body, that they were not only human. They established that such a person could look for others by writing honestly and waiting for an answer. They gave the community its oldest symbol and, at one remove, its name.
They also left a tone: light-hearted, courteous, a little formal, more interested in kinship than in argument. Later decades were not always so gentle. But the tone is still there to be found in the community's better writing, and the library's own essays try to keep to it. The elfkin page describes the kintype with which it all began, and the page on otherkin, spirituality and religion follows the spiritual inheritance of those first circles.