The Otherkin Glade
Otherkin, Spirituality and Religion
The otherkin community was born in a spiritual setting, and many otherkin still understand themselves in spiritual terms. Most also say, firmly, that being otherkin is not a religion. Both statements are true, and this page explains how.
Two things that are both true
Ask an otherkin whether their identity is spiritual and many will say yes. Ask whether it is their religion and nearly all will say no. To an outsider that can sound like a contradiction. It is not one. A person can believe that they have a soul, and hold a view about where that soul came from, without belonging to a church, keeping a rite or sharing a creed with anybody.
The overview of otherkin says briefly that otherkin identity is not a religion. This page looks at the question more closely: where the spiritual strand in the community came from, what otherkin commonly believe, what they do not, and why scholars who study religion have found the community so hard to classify.
Spiritual roots
The therian community began among readers of werewolf stories and had to work out afterward what it believed. The otherkin community began the other way around. Its earliest members, the small elven circles of the 1970s, moved in the pagan and magical networks of their day. Their letters appeared in pagan periodicals, and they wrote about magic, the natural world and the nature of the soul as a matter of course. The page on the elven letters tells that story.
The community that grew from those circles kept the inheritance. Its founding question, as the history page puts it, was "what kind of soul do I have?" The first scholarly article on the otherkin, published in 2006, accordingly placed them beside the modern pagan movement, though its author called this a provisional arrangement and warned that it obscured what the participants themselves were concerned with.
What otherkin commonly believe
There is no list of otherkin beliefs, and no one is in a position to draw one up. What follows are ideas that appear often in what otherkin have written about themselves. Any given person may hold several, one or none.
- A soul that is not human. The commonest spiritual account is the simplest: the body is human and the soul is that of another kind of being.
- Earlier lives. Many understand their kintype as something they were in a previous existence. The page on memories and past lives discusses how carefully such impressions are usually handled.
- Other worlds. Since dragons and elves are not found in the visible world, many otherkin suppose that there are more worlds than this one, and that their kind belongs to another of them. The idea of many parallel worlds is widespread in the community.
- A soul that arrived. A few describe a spirit that entered or joined them during this life, sometimes called a walk-in.
- Experiences out of the body. Some describe taking the form of their kintype in trance or in a vivid inner journey, which the community calls an astral shift. Like every kind of shift, it is an experience and involves no change to the body.
- A closeness to nature. Many describe themselves as unusually attuned to the natural world or to the moods of other people. This is offered as a description of temperament and not as a power.
Beside all of these stand otherkin who hold none of them. A psychological understanding, in which the dragon or the elf is the truest available shape for something in a person's own nature, has always been present and has grown more common. Others relate their identity to their neurodivergence, or to being part of a plural system. And many are content to say that they do not know. The same range of views among therians is set out under explaining therianthropy.
Why most otherkin say it is not a religion
When otherkin say that their identity is not a religion, they usually have plain things in mind.
- No creed. There is nothing an otherkin is required to believe. Two people with the same kintype may explain it in opposite ways.
- No scripture and no clergy. There are respected essays and long-standing members, but no text or person holds authority.
- No worship and no required practice. Nobody is expected to pray, keep a festival or perform a rite.
- No organization. The community has no central body and no membership. It consists of forums, groups and friendships.
- Every faith and none. Otherkin are pagans, Christians, Jews, Buddhists, atheists and people of no settled view. Their identity sits beside their religion and does not replace it.
There is also a matter of emphasis. For most otherkin the heart of the matter is an experience, a lasting sense of being a certain kind of being, and not a doctrine. The beliefs come afterward, as attempts to explain the experience, and can be changed without the experience changing. The therian community reached the same position, as its page on common misconceptions notes.
How scholars have seen it
Scholars of religion were among the first academics to take an interest in the otherkin, and they have not agreed about what they found. Following the library's practice, they are not named here.
- A religious dimension, but not a religion. One scholar of religious studies concluded that otherkin beliefs plainly have a religious side, while judging that the community cannot comfortably be said to fit a strict definition of religion.
- Doing the work of a religion. The same line of thought holds that the community does for its members some of what religions do: it offers a way of making sense of one's existence, and a group of people who share it. On this view it sustains an alternative picture of how the world is ordered.
- Something like a religion that lives online. Others have called it a new religious movement, or nearly one, that in some of its forms exists almost entirely on the internet.
- Not a religion at all. More recent researchers, working from the stories otherkin tell about their own lives, have criticized the habit of treating the community as a religion or a spirituality, on the ground that this is not how most of its members understand it.
- A different question altogether. One scholar has suggested that identifying as other than human is less a matter of illness than of politics: a way of declining the usual account of what a person must be.
Critics have had their say as well. One writer has described the otherkin as an expression of dissatisfaction with the modern world, and has objected that they lift the figures of old fairy belief out of the settings that gave them meaning. The second point deserves to be taken seriously, and thoughtful otherkin do take it seriously, as the next section describes.
The page on what research says describes the wider body of academic work, including studies that set the question of religion aside.
Personal practice
Some otherkin do keep spiritual practices that are colored by their identity. A person may meditate with their kintype in mind, keep a small shelf of objects that speak to it, mark the turning of the seasons, or write down dreams. These are private habits. They vary from person to person, they are not taught as a system, and many otherkin have none.
Those who follow a religion fit their identity within it in their own ways. An otherkin who is a pagan may find the two sit together easily. An otherkin who is a Christian may think of their kintype as part of how they were made. The library takes no view on these matters, which belong to each person and to their tradition.
One courtesy is worth stating. Many of the beings that otherkin identify as come from the beliefs of living peoples, and some are sacred to them. An otherkin's sense of being such a creature does not make them a member of the tradition it comes from, or an authority on it, and does not entitle them to its closed practices. The pages on faekin and on mythic beasts say more about respect for the sources.
Where the community draws lines
A community with a spiritual strand needs some safeguards, and the otherkin community has developed them.
- No physical claims. Otherkin do not claim to change their bodies, to fly or to work wonders. People who say that they can are not generally believed, and are discouraged from saying so. The page on claims of physical shifting explains the reasoning, which holds for otherkin as for therians.
- Experience is personal. A memory, a vision or a conviction is evidence for the person who has it and for no one else. Nobody is obliged to accept another person's account of a past life.
- No one may tell you what you are. A person who offers to reveal your kintype, read your past lives or confirm your nature, above all for money, secrecy or loyalty, should be avoided.
- Agreement is not required. A spiritual otherkin and a psychological one are describing the same kind of experience, and neither is the more genuine.
If you are thinking this through
You do not need a theory of the soul in order to be otherkin, and you do not need to give up the one you have. If your identity sits comfortably within your faith, or within your lack of one, nothing needs to change. If a spiritual explanation brings you meaning, hold it as yours. If it does not, set it down; the experience will still be there.
An understanding of this kind should bring a measure of peace. If a belief about your nature frightens you, isolates you, or leaves you unsure what is real, please talk to a doctor or a mental health professional, and see the page on wellbeing and care.