The Wolf Walk
Natural Explanations for the Werewolf
For more than a century, physicians, historians and folklorists have looked for something real behind the werewolf: a disease, a poison, a kind of person, a kind of wolf. Each proposal explains a little. None explains the legend.
The search for a cause
It is a natural question. A belief found in so many countries over so many centuries, people reason, must rest on something. Since the nineteenth century a long line of writers has tried to say what that something was, and their answers have entered popular knowledge so thoroughly that many people now "know" that werewolves were really sufferers from one disease or another.
The search has a difficulty built into it. There is no single werewolf to explain. The page on werewolves around the world shows how much the figure differs from one country to the next, and the modern image, hairy, moon-struck and infectious, is a composite assembled largely by fiction and film. A theory built to fit that composite may fit nothing that anyone in the past actually believed.
This page takes the main proposals in turn and asks of each what it accounts for and where it falls short. Nothing here is medical advice, and the conditions named are described only as far as the argument needs.
A sickness of the mind
The oldest natural explanation is the physicians' own. From late antiquity onward, medical writers described a melancholy in which sufferers believed themselves wolves, went out at night, and haunted graveyards. That tradition is followed on the page about trials, physicians and skeptics, and its modern descendant is clinical lycanthropy, a rare symptom of serious mental illness in which a person believes that their body is changing into an animal's.
The condition is real, and a few of the accused in the old trials probably had something like it. The shepherd boy described among the cases on record seems to have believed everything he said. But it is very rare, and it explains only why an occasional person claimed to be a werewolf. It does not explain why whole communities believed that their neighbors were.
Rabies
Rabies has the strongest claim of any disease. It is carried by wolves and dogs and passed on by a bite. An infected animal loses its fear of people, attacks without cause and bites again and again. A person who develops the disease may become agitated and violent, struggle to swallow, and recoil from water, before dying. Before modern medicine there was no treatment and no survivor.
A rabid wolf was therefore the most dangerous animal a medieval village could meet, and its attacks must have fed the fear of wolves that behaved as no wolf should. The idea of a dreadful change passed from wolf to human by a bite also looks very like the modern werewolf.
That is the weakness of the theory. The bite belongs to the fiction of the last century and is almost absent from older belief, in which a person became a werewolf by a skin, a salve or a curse. And a human sufferer from rabies does not recover each morning. The disease shaped the fear of wolves more than it shaped the legend.
Porphyria
In 1964 an English physician proposed that werewolves were sufferers from a rare inherited disorder of the blood. In its most severe form the condition makes the skin so sensitive to sunlight that it blisters and scars, so that a sufferer might go out only at night. The scarring can be disfiguring, the teeth may be stained reddish, and extra hair may grow on the face. Here, it was argued, was the origin of a creature that walked by night, looked terrible and had red in its mouth.
The proposal was widely reported and is still repeated. It has not worn well. The form of the disease in question is exceedingly rare, far too rare to account for a belief held across a continent. The werewolf of folklore was not a disfigured person: in human form it looked like anyone else, and in wolf form it looked like a wolf. And it has been pointed out that the list of "werewolf features" the theory set out to explain was drawn in part from a nineteenth-century report about a shape-changing being in the East Indies, which belongs to a different tradition altogether. The theory explained a picture of the werewolf that the old sources do not give.
Hypertrichosis
A few people are born with a condition that covers the face and body in long, fine hair. It is sometimes called werewolf syndrome in the popular press. The best-known historical case is a man born in the Canary Islands in the sixteenth century, who was brought as a child to the French court, given a gentleman's education, and married; several of his children inherited the condition, and portraits of the family survive. In the nineteenth century, people with the condition were exhibited in shows under names that compared them to dogs and lions.
These lives are worth remembering for their own sake. As an explanation of the werewolf they do not serve. The family at the French court were treated as marvels, and no one took them for werewolves. In the trial records of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, hairiness is hardly ever mentioned among the signs: the accused were ordinary-looking beggars, herdsmen and farmers. The hairy wolf-man is a creation of the film studios of the 1930s and 1940s, and the link with this condition was made afterward. It is also a hurtful name to give to people who have it.
Poisoned bread and witches' salves
Rye and other grains can be infected, in damp years, by a fungus that makes the flour poisonous. People who eat the bread may suffer burning pains, convulsions and visions. It has been suggested that outbreaks of this poisoning lay behind some episodes of witch-hunting, and that people who had eaten such bread might have seen their neighbors, or themselves, as beasts.
A related idea concerns the ointments that the accused confessed to using. Recipes written down by their accusers name plants that can cause delirium, and some writers have wondered whether a salve absorbed through the skin could have produced vivid dreams of running as a wolf. The page on signs, causes and cures calls this an interesting conjecture and no more, and the same must be said of the poisoned bread. Neither can be tested against the surviving records. Neither explains why the visions took the shape of a wolf, unless the legend already existed to give them one. Several of the plants in question are deadly, and no such recipe should ever be tried.
Wild children and people of the woods
Europe was long fascinated by children found living alone in the forest. The most famous was a boy of about twelve discovered in the woods of northern Germany in 1725. He went on all fours, ate what he could find and could not speak. He was brought to the English court as a curiosity, where a princess tried without success to have him taught, and he was later lodged with a farming family in the country, where he lived quietly into old age. He never learned more than a few words. It is now thought, from a portrait and from descriptions of him, that he had a rare inborn condition and had probably been abandoned.
Such children, and the hermits, outcasts and half-starved wanderers who also lived at the forest's edge, show how real the figure of the wild human was. The recluse of Dole and the runaway boy of the Landes, both described among the cases on record, were people of this kind, and so was the outlaw whom northern law called a wolf, discussed under wolf warriors and outlaws. They explain who was likely to be accused. They do not explain the belief that such a person wore a wolf's body.
Real wolves
The plainest explanation is the animal itself. Healthy wild wolves very seldom attack people, as the page on the real wolf makes clear. But the past was not always like the present. In hard winters, after wars that left the dead unburied, and where the wolves' own prey had been hunted out, attacks did happen, and the victims were most often children sent out alone to mind animals or gather wood. A preacher in a German city listed these very causes in a sermon on werewolves printed in 1516: hunger, cold, and wolves that had learned the taste of human flesh.
A wolf that behaved with unusual boldness or cunning asked for an unusual explanation. Werewolf accusations cluster in regions with many wolves and fade as the wolves are killed off. And the Slavic picture of the sorrowful, enchanted werewolf that lingers near the village, described under Slavic werewolves, may owe something to the sight of old or sick wolves that could no longer hunt and came to the edge of the fields for scraps.
Rumor, theft and convenient stories
Some explanations need no disease and no wolf, only human nature. Collectors of werewolf legends in eastern Europe noted several ordinary ways in which a story could begin.
- Thieves. People who stole livestock had good reason to let it be thought that a werewolf was about.
- Wanderers. Beggars went from village to village telling how they had once been wolves, or were searching for a relative who had been turned into one, and were given food and coins for the tale.
- Accidents. A hunter who had shot a person, by mistake or otherwise, might say that he had fired at a wolf and found a human body.
- Grudges. An accusation settled old scores. The case of the German town that hanged a dead wolf in the clothes of a hated official shows how much such stories had to do with the living.
- Distance. Tellers placed the event in the next village, and those in the next village placed it in the one beyond. One collector observed that the farther from its supposed home a story was written down, the more wonders it contained.
To these must be added the courts. A person under torture will confess to whatever the questioner already believes, and a confession once printed becomes the model for the next.
The explanations weighed
| Proposal | What it helps to explain | Where it falls short |
|---|---|---|
| Illness of mind | Why a few people sincerely claimed to be wolves | Very rare; does not explain a community's belief |
| Rabies | Fearless, biting wolves; the terror of a bite | The bite is a modern addition; sufferers do not change back |
| Porphyria | Little, on inspection | Far too rare; the folk werewolf was not disfigured |
| Hypertrichosis | The look of the film wolf-man | Hairiness is almost absent from the trials |
| Poisoned grain and salves | Possibly, some visions and dreams | Untestable; does not explain why a wolf |
| Wild children and outcasts | Who was likely to be accused | Not the belief in a wolf's body |
| Real wolves | The fear, the timing and the places | Not the human being inside the wolf |
| Rumor and interest | How particular stories started and spread | Not why the idea was there to be used |
No single key
The honest conclusion is that the werewolf has no one origin. Legends are not fixed things with a cause, like an illness. They are told and retold, and each teller adds and drops details. Some features of the werewolf were observed, some were borrowed from other peoples, and some were simply invented because they made a better story. A disease may have colored the picture here and there. None of them painted it.
What lies under all the versions is older and simpler than any diagnosis: the knowledge that people lived beside a clever and dangerous animal, and the knowledge that people themselves can be savage. The page on wolf warriors and outlaws looks at one more source, the men who put on the wolf on purpose.
One practical point follows. The medical theories have left behind the habit of calling real conditions by the werewolf's name. People who live with those conditions are not figures of legend, and neither are therians, whose identity involves no belief in bodily change and is not an illness. The page on common misconceptions says more.