From the essay shelf

On Being Corrected Kindly

Six weeks after I first read the word therian, I wrote a guide to therianthropy for newcomers. I would like that sentence to stand alone for a moment so that its full absurdity can be appreciated.

In my defense, I had been busy. I had read a great many short posts and watched a great many short videos. I had filled a notebook with definitions, each copied from somewhere and tidied up. I had sorted them into categories of my own devising, with headings. It was a handsome piece of work. I posted it in the introductions board of a forum I had joined that month, under a title that promised to help people understand the subject clearly, and I added that I would be glad to make corrections if anybody had any.

I did not expect to be taken up on that.

The reply

For some days nothing happened. Then a reply arrived from a member who had been there for many years, one of the people who look after the place. It opened with an apology for having taken so long. It then went through my guide from top to bottom.

It was long. It took each of my headings in turn. Where I had been right it said so, briefly: "correct," or "largely correct." Where I had been nearly right it said "almost," and then explained the part I had missed. Where I had been wrong it said what was actually the case, and why, and in two places told me where I could read the original discussion for myself.

There was a great deal of "almost."

What I had gotten wrong

Some of it was detail. I had defined two terms the wrong way around. I had presented as a standard category a word that, it turned out, one person had coined for their own experience and hardly anyone else used. I had written that most therians understand their identity psychologically, and was told, mildly, that nobody knows that: every corner of the community sees only its own members, many of the people who began it had seen the matter as spiritual, and there are therians who have never been online at all.

Some of it went deeper. Throughout the guide I had written that a therian "connects to" an animal. Again and again the reply amended it: it is being, not just connecting to. I had copied the softer phrase from a dozen places without noticing that it described something else entirely.

And one thing was serious. I had included, as one type among the others, the idea that some therians are physically their animal. I had not thought about it. It had been on somebody's list. The reply did not scold. It said that the matter was disputed and had a history, that such claims had in the past led to real harm, to groups built around a leader, to people being taken for money, and that the forum had a rule about it for that reason. I had been handing newcomers something with a hook in it and had not known.

How it felt

I would like to report that I received all this with grace. In fact I read it with my face burning. I am, as far as I can yet tell, some kind of marten: quick, inquisitive, and a good deal bolder than my size warrants. Everything in me wanted to go up the nearest tree.

What kept me on the ground was the tone. There was not a sneer anywhere in it. Nobody had told me to read the frequently asked questions and come back when I knew something. Nobody had called me any of the names that I later learned are kept for people like me. An older member had sat down after a hard week and spent what must have been an hour taking my work seriously enough to fix it. Near the end they wrote that the forum held a great deal more on every one of these subjects, built up over many years by many people, and that I was welcome to it.

I wrote back to say thank you, and meant it. Then I added a note at the head of my guide saying that parts of it were wrong and that readers should go on to the reply beneath. It is still there. I have thought since of deleting the whole thing, and have decided to leave it, corrections and all. It is a more useful document now than it was when it was merely confident.

What the words are for

A second, shorter thing reached me that same month, and I have kept it beside the first. In an older thread, under somebody else's list of terms, one of the staff had written a few lines to the effect that therianthropy is not about picking labels. It is about being yourself. If you want us to understand you, they said, come and tell us what your experience is like. That will do more than any word on the list.

I had needed to hear that, because I had been treating the vocabulary as a set of drawers and myself as a thing to be filed. I knew twenty terms and had tried on most of them. I could have told you which three I "was." I could not have told you, in plain sentences, what actually happened in me on an ordinary day, because I had never stopped collecting definitions for long enough to look.

So I put the notebook of terms away and began another, with nothing in it but what I noticed. It was thinner. It was also the first true thing I had written on the subject.

What is owed in both directions

I have been here a little longer now. Not long. But long enough to have seen the next wave of newcomers arrive, each with a handsome guide, and to have felt in myself the beginning of a sigh.

I try to remember, when I feel it, what was done for me. It would have cost that older member nothing to ignore my post, and very little to flatten it in a line. Either would have taught me that the place was not for me, and I might well have left and gone on repeating my mistakes to people who knew no better than I did. The correction kept me. The kindness is why the correction worked.

So I think something is owed in both directions. Those of us who are new owe the old hands some patience with being told we are wrong, since we generally are, and some curiosity about the long conversation that was going on before we came in. The library's page on contested words explains why certain mistakes sting more than we expect. And those who have been here for years owe the newcomer what was once given to them, or what they wish had been: the assumption of good faith, the plain fact, and no name-calling.

I do not yet know for certain what I am. A marten, probably. I am in no hurry now, which is new. But I know what kind of member I would like to be when I have been here twenty years, and I have a long reply saved in a folder to remind me.

Pieces in the stacks are written under pen names. Personal pieces are composite accounts that gather experiences commonly described by therians and otherkin, and are offered as illustration, not as testimony about any one person. See the editorial principles.

Shelved under Essays Community

This page was last tended on .