From the essay shelf

The Walk Where She Told Me

My daughter told me on the way back from the store. I have since learned that this is common. Children choose a walk or a car ride for difficult things, because nobody has to look at anybody. At the time I only noticed that she had gone quiet two streets earlier and was carrying the milk in both arms like something that might be taken from her.

"Mom," she said, "I need to tell you something and you have to not laugh."

I said I would not laugh. I am glad of that now, because it was the only useful thing I managed for some time.

"I'm a therian," she said. "I'm a hare."

She was eleven.

What I already knew

I would like to say that I was astonished. I was not, quite. There had been a mask drying on her windowsill for a month, a long brown face with ears made of cardboard and fabric, better made than I would have believed. There had been a request, some weeks before, for me to buy a tail from a website, which I had refused without really asking what it was for. And there were older things, which only arranged themselves into a pattern afterward.

She has always gone still. As a very small child, if something startled her, she did not cry or run to me. She froze, completely, for a second or two, with her eyes wide, and then she was gone across the room faster than I could follow. I used to tell people about it as a funny thing. She has always slept in a sort of nest, pressed down into the blankets, and she has always been at her brightest in the half hour before dark, when the rest of us are tired. None of that is proof of anything. I mention it because when she said the word hare, part of me thought, well, yes.

The rest of me thought a number of other things, and I am sorry to say that the first one I spoke aloud was, "Is this something from the internet?"

What I got wrong

Her face closed. I watched it happen. She said, "I knew you'd say that," and we walked the rest of the way home without talking, and she went upstairs.

It was not a wicked thing to ask. It is what every parent of my generation would ask. But I understand now what she heard in it. She heard me say that it was not hers, that someone had put it into her, and that I would be dealing with it as a problem of supervision. She had spent weeks finding the courage, and it took me one sentence to tell her that I thought she was only copying.

I did two sensible things that evening, more by luck than judgment. I did not go up and argue. And after she was asleep I sat down and read, for about three hours, everything calm that I could find. A great deal of what is written is not calm. I learned to close anything with a shocked headline.

What I took from that reading can be put shortly. The word is older than I am comfortable admitting; adults have used it since before I left school. It does not mean she believes she has a hare's body, and she does not. It is not an illness. And the psychologists who are asked about it all say much the same thing, which is that a parent's business is to stay calm, to ask what it means to the child, and to keep an eye on the ordinary things: school, friends, sleep, mood.

The next morning I apologized. I said, "I asked the wrong question yesterday. Will you tell me what it's like?" She looked at me for a while to see whether I meant it. Then she told me, for most of an hour, and I learned more about the inside of my daughter's head than I had in the previous year.

What she said

She said the word had come from a video, yes, but the feeling had not. The feeling had been there as long as she could remember, and she had assumed that everyone had it. She said that she knew perfectly well she was a girl with two legs and that I did not need to explain that. She said that sometimes, mostly outdoors, mostly in the evening, the hare part came forward and she felt long in the leg and wanted very badly to run, and that it lasted a minute or two and was the nicest feeling she knew. She said she could feel the ears. She showed me where.

She said she had chosen hare and not rabbit after reading about both, because rabbits live in crowds underground and hares live alone in the open, and she was a hare. I had not known the difference. I do now.

I asked what she wanted from me. She thought about it and said, "Just don't be weird about it. And don't tell Grandma yet."

The rules we made

I am not a person who can simply approve of everything, and I do not think children want that. We sat down that weekend and made some rules, and I let her argue with them.

The mask is for home, the backyard, and the park with her friend, and so is the tail, which she ended up making herself out of yarn. They do not come to school, to church lunch with her grandmother, or to the dentist. She thought that was fair, and seemed faintly surprised that I had thought she might want to wear a hare's face to the dentist.

Being a hare is never a reason. If she is rude, she is a rude girl, and "I was shifting" will not be heard. She agreed to this at once and with some dignity. It turns out the people she reads online say the same.

The running on all fours, which I had seen her doing in the backyard and which had alarmed me more than anything, happens on grass and after a warm-up. I looked up what it does to wrists. It is a sport like any other, and I would not let her do gymnastics on concrete either.

Nothing is posted with her face, her school or our street in it, and I see what goes up. She did not like this one. It stayed.

In return I agreed to stop saying "phase" in her hearing, and to buy the fabric for a second mask if she would show me how she made the first.

The hard evening

It has not all been easy, and I would not trust this account if it said so. In the spring a girl at school found out, I do not know how. For a week or so there were noises in the hallway, and then someone filmed my daughter on the playground from behind and put it up with a caption. She came home gray. She did not want to tell me, because she thought I would say that this was what came of it.

I did not say that. I am rather proud of not saying it, because I thought it. What I said was that being laughed at was not her doing, and then I called the school. Her teacher was better than I had feared. She did not ask my daughter to explain herself. She treated it as what it was, which was one child being unkind to another, and dealt with it under the rules they already had. The video came down. The noises stopped, mostly.

What I noticed was that the hare was not the wound. The wound was the laughing. She was no less a hare the following week, and no more. She was simply a child who had been laughed at and then stood up for, and the second mattered as much to her as the first.

Her grandmother, and her brother

We told my mother at Easter. I had dreaded it. My mother listened to the whole explanation with her hands folded and then said, "Well, your grandfather thought he was a great deal of things, and none of them as sensible as a hare." She has since knitted a pair of ear-warmers that she insists are a coincidence.

Her brother, who is fourteen, said it was the stupidest thing he had ever heard. He kept that up for about two weeks. He then spent a whole Saturday helping her wire the ears on the second mask so that they would stand up properly, and I have not heard the word stupid since.

What I do not know

I do not know whether she will be saying this at twenty. Nobody can tell me, and I have stopped asking. I have read accounts by people in their fifties who have felt this way all their lives and who describe quiet, ordinary, contented existences, with jobs and marriages. I have also been eleven, and I remember being several things with great certainty that year.

It took me some months to see that I did not need to know. If it passes, it will pass without our having fought about it, and she will remember that I listened. If it stays, then I have a daughter who is, in some way I only partly understand, a hare, and who told me herself, on a walk, when she could have kept it from me. I know which of those two things I would have been sorrier to miss.

I watch what I was told to watch. She sleeps. She eats. She has two good friends and is mystified by long division, which is all in order. She laughs more than she did a year ago. If any of that changed, I would take her to the doctor, and I would say at the start that she is a therian and that I know it is not an illness, and that I had come about the other thing.

Yesterday evening I looked out of the kitchen window at about the time the light goes. She was at the far end of the yard, standing completely still on the wet grass with her head up, looking at nothing that I could see. Then she ran. I have watched her do that since she could walk. It was only last year that she told me what it was.

Pieces in the stacks are written under pen names. Personal pieces are composite accounts that gather experiences commonly described by therians and otherkin, and are offered as illustration, not as testimony about any one person. See the editorial principles.

Shelved under Essays Community Newcomers

This page was last tended on .