The Therian Grove
Extinct Theriotypes
A paleotherian is a therian whose animal no longer lives. There is no one to watch and nothing to visit except bones, and the identity has to be built on what the ground has kept.
What a paleotherian is
A paleotherian identifies as an animal that is extinct. The animal may have vanished within living memory, like the thylacine, or tens of millions of years ago, like the great dinosaurs. The word says nothing about how the identity is felt. A paleotherian may shift or not, have one theriotype or several, and hold a spiritual or a psychological understanding, like any other therian.
What sets the experience apart is the nature of the evidence. A wolf therian can spend a lifetime watching wolves. A dire wolf therian has a skeleton, some chemistry, and the careful guesses of people who study such things. That is less than one would wish, and a good deal more than nothing.
The animals most often named
- Dire wolves lived in the Americas until roughly ten thousand years ago. They were about the size of the largest gray wolves, more heavily built, with stronger jaws. Study of their ancient remains has shown that they were not close kin to the gray wolf at all, but a separate branch of the dog family that had gone its own way for millions of years. Their coat, their voice and their family life are not known.
- Saber-toothed cats were not tigers, and belonged to a branch of the cat family that left no living descendants. The best known was a powerful, short-tailed ambush hunter, built more like a bear than like a cheetah. Healed injuries in some skeletons suggest to many researchers that hurt animals survived for a time, perhaps within a group.
- Cave lions ranged across the cold grasslands of Europe and Asia during the Ice Age. Ice Age painters drew them without manes, and frozen cubs have been found with pale, thick fur.
- Mammoths were close relatives of living elephants. The woolly mammoth had small ears, a thick coat and a hump of fat, and its tusks show a long life recorded in growth rings. A last small population survived on an Arctic island until about four thousand years ago.
- Cave bears and giant deer. The cave bear was a large bear of Ice Age Europe that fed mostly on plants. The giant deer, sometimes called the Irish elk, was neither an elk nor confined to Ireland, and carried the widest antlers of any known deer.
- Animals lost in recent centuries. The thylacine, a striped marsupial hunter of Tasmania, died out in the twentieth century. The aurochs, wild ancestor of cattle, died out in the seventeenth. The dodo, the great auk and the passenger pigeon all vanished through human action. For these there are written accounts, museum skins, and in a few cases photographs or film.
- Dinosaurs and their neighbors. Dinosaurs ruled the land for well over a hundred million years. Those most often named as theriotypes are the swift, feathered hunters of the dromaeosaur family and the great tyrannosaurs, followed by the long-necked plant eaters. Flying pterosaurs and the great marine reptiles lived beside the dinosaurs but were not dinosaurs themselves.
What can be known, and what cannot
| Evidence | What it can tell | What it leaves open |
|---|---|---|
| Bones and teeth | Size, build, diet, gait, age, old injuries | Color, voice, most behavior |
| Trackways | Speed, stride, whether animals traveled together | Why they were traveling |
| Frozen and preserved remains | Fur, skin, stomach contents, sometimes feathers and their color | Rare, and limited to a few species and climates |
| Ancient art | How Ice Age people saw mammoths, lions and bison in life | The artist's purpose |
| Living relatives | Reasonable guesses about senses, parenting and social life | Where the extinct animal differed |
| Written accounts and photographs | Behavior of animals lost in recent centuries | Often brief, and made of captive or hunted animals |
The picture also changes. Within living memory dinosaurs have gone from slow, scaly, tail-dragging reptiles to quick, warm-bodied animals, many of them feathered, and further changes are certain. A paleotherian does well to hold the details loosely. An identity pinned to one illustration may be pinned to something that will be redrawn.
What paleotherians commonly describe
These are patterns often reported. None is a test.
- A body unlike any living one. Phantom tails held stiff and level for balance, heavy forequarters, long sabers that make the jaw feel wrong, a trunk, a coat of thick wool. Some describe three-toed feet or a clawed hand where no modern animal has one.
- A world that is gone. A pull toward open, cold, grassy country, or toward warm fern forest, that no present landscape quite answers.
- Kinship with living relatives. Dinosaur therians often feel close to birds, mammoth therians to elephants, and many recognize a movement or a posture in a relative before they find it in a reconstruction.
- Scale. A sense of great size, or for the small feathered hunters, of lightness and speed.
- A particular grief. Some describe sorrow that their animal has no living kind. It is a real form of the ache discussed under species dysphoria, and the essay Living With the Ache may be a comfort.
Extinct animals and their living look-alikes
| Often confused | The real difference | What it may mean in experience |
|---|---|---|
| Dire wolf and gray wolf | Separate branches of the dog family; the dire wolf was heavier, with a stronger bite | Weight and power, or range and endurance |
| Saber-toothed cat and tiger | Not close relatives; the saber-tooth was stocky and short-tailed | An ambush and a grapple, or a long stalk |
| Cave lion and lion | Close kin; the cave lion lived in cold country and seems to have lacked a mane | Cold open ground, or warm savanna |
| Mammoth and elephant | Close kin; the woolly mammoth was built for cold | Wool, small ears and snow, or bare skin and heat |
| Small feathered dinosaur and bird of prey | Birds are living dinosaurs; the extinct hunters had toothed jaws, clawed hands and long bony tails | Hands and a balancing tail, or wings and flight |
| Pterosaur and dinosaur | Related but separate groups; pterosaurs flew on wings of skin | Flight on a membrane, quite unlike a bird's |
It is worth asking honestly whether a living animal would fit as well. Someone who feels a heavy wolf may be a dire wolf, or may be a large gray wolf who met the dire wolf first in a story. Only patient comparison will tell.
Myths that mislead
- The film dinosaur. The famous hunting dinosaur of the cinema is shown far larger than the real animal, which stood about as high as a turkey and was feathered. Films are made to thrill.
- The giant dire wolf. Fantasy has made the dire wolf the size of a horse. The real one was a large wolf, not a monster.
- The saber-toothed tiger. It was not a tiger, and its long teeth were fairly fragile, suited to a careful killing bite and not to a struggle.
- Extinct means unfit. Animals die out because the world changes, through climate, through the loss of prey, and very often through human hands. Many extinct animals flourished for far longer than our own species has existed.
- The dragon in the rock. Old finds of great bones may have fed legends of giants and dragons. Those belong to story, and a dinosaur therian is not a dragon, though a few people feel close to both.
- Extinct means more impressive. A paleotherian is not a grander kind of therian. The page on theriotypes warns against choosing the admired animal, and the warning applies with some force to animals with sabers.
Respect for the animals and their remains
Fossils are a record that cannot be replaced. Collecting is forbidden or restricted in many places, and a bone removed from where it lay loses most of what it could have told. Leave finds where they are, note the spot, and report anything that looks important to a local museum. Museums themselves are the nearest a paleotherian can come to the animal, and most people find a visit moving.
For animals lost in recent centuries, the story is one of human carelessness. Many paleotherians find that their identity leads naturally to caring about the living relatives: wolves, elephants, wild cattle, flightless birds and the wild places they need.
Finding your way slowly
Loving dinosaurs settles nothing, and neither does a childhood spent drawing mammoths. Many people love these animals. The method on the page about theriotypes applies here as everywhere: record what you actually experience, learn what is really known, and compare over months.
Read from museums and from people who work on the bones, and be wary of confident detail from anywhere else. Where the evidence runs out, say so, to yourself first of all. "Some large extinct cat, I cannot tell which" is an honest theriotype, and may be the most accurate one available. A few paleotherians find in time that their identity takes in a whole vanished branch, and that cladotherian describes it better.