From the story shelf

The Third Knife

Two neighbors lived at the end of a village, with one fence between them. One was rich and one was poor.

The rich man had forty acres, a tiled stove and a horse for every day of the week. He had something else as well, though it was not talked of. There were things he could do. His rye never lodged in the rain. A man who quarreled with him in the spring would find his cow dry by midsummer. People were polite to him, and did not linger at his gate.

The poor man had three acres of sour ground and a wife and a great many children. He was a good man, which is to say that he worked hard and wished no one ill, and it had not made him any richer. All his life he had plowed with a borrowed horse and paid for the borrowing in labor, so that he was always working another man's land when he should have been working his own.

One autumn, after nine years of saving, he had enough. He went to the fair and came home leading a horse. It was not a fine horse. It was a small brown mare, past her youth, with one white foot. But she was sound, and she was his, and the whole family came out into the road to look at her. The children fed her bread from their hands.

The rich man stood at his fence and looked too. He said it was a good thing to see a neighbor getting on in the world. But he did not like it. He did not need the poor man's labor, and he did not want the poor man's mare. He only did not like to see the fence between them grow any lower.

That evening the poor man led his mare out to the common pasture beyond the alders and hobbled her there, as everyone did. Then, because she was the first horse he had ever owned and he could not quite bear to leave her, he did not go home. He sat down among the alders at the pasture's edge with his coat pulled around him, and watched her graze in the last of the light.

So he was there when his neighbor came.

The rich man came along the ditch, quietly, looking about him. He stopped at a bare patch of ground not twenty paces from the alders. He took three knives from inside his coat, and he pushed them into the earth by their handles, one beyond another in a row, with the blades standing up. Then he took off his coat and his boots and laid them by. He said something that the poor man could not hear.

And he threw himself forward and went head over heels across the first knife.

When he came up on the far side of it, he had a wolf's head. The poor man saw it clearly against the pale sky: the long jaw, the ears. It was a man's body still, in a linen shirt, with a wolf's head upon the neck.

He went over the second knife, and his whole body was a wolf's, the chest and the back and the gray flanks, but he stood up out of the tumble on a man's two white legs.

He went over the third, and the legs were a wolf's legs, and there was nothing of the man left to see. A big gray wolf shook itself, and looked once toward the village, and went off across the pasture at a lope.

The poor man could not move. He heard his mare scream. He heard her try to run in her hobbles, and fall. After that he heard nothing for a while, and then the sounds of a wolf at its work. He sat among the alders with his fist in his mouth so as not to cry out, and the tears ran down into his beard. Nine years.

When he could think again, he thought this: that the wolf would come back the way it had gone.

He crept out of the alders on his hands and knees to the bare patch of ground. There were the three knives, standing in their row. He did not know which mattered, or whether any did. He was not a knowing man. He only understood that they were a road, and that a road can be broken. He took hold of the farthest one, the third, and drew it out of the earth. It came easily. He put it inside his shirt, against his skin, where it lay as cold as a fish, and he crawled back into the alders and waited.

The wolf came back before moonrise, heavy and slow, licking its jaws. It circled to the near end of the row, for the knives had to be taken in the same order going home as going out. It did not look at them. Why should it? It had done this many times.

It rolled over the first knife, and came up with a man's head. The poor man saw his neighbor's face, pleased and sleepy, on a wolf's shoulders.

It rolled over the second, and there was his neighbor's body, in the linen shirt.

It threw itself forward where the third knife should have been, and rolled, and stood up. It looked down.

The rich man stood in the pasture in his shirt, on the hind legs of a wolf. They were gray and crooked, with the hocks bent backward and the long clawed feet. He stood very still. Then he went over the place again, and again, faster each time, tearing at the turf with his hands, feeling for the blade. He stopped, and for a long time he did not move at all. And then he lifted his head and looked at the alders.

The poor man did not breathe.

Whether his neighbor saw him there, he never knew. The rich man said nothing. He took up his coat and his boots. He could not get the boots on. He wrapped the coat about his legs as well as he could, and he went home along the ditch in the dark, slowly, with a gait that was not a man's.

In the morning the poor man buried what was left of his mare. He wept again, and his wife wept, and the children.

The rich man was not seen for a week. When he came out, he was wearing a long coat that reached to the ground, and tall boots made specially by a cobbler in the town, wide in the leg. He wore them from that day in every weather, at haymaking and in the bathhouse and, they say, in his bed. He walked with a stick. Dogs would not stay in a yard he entered. And his luck went out of him. His rye lodged like anyone else's. A cow of his went dry, and people noticed it.

He never accused his neighbor, and his neighbor never accused him. They nodded to one another over the fence for another twenty years. But in the spring after that autumn, a brown mare was found one morning tied to the poor man's gate, a young one, with no word about where she had come from. The poor man looked at her for a long time. Then he led her in.

He kept the knife. He never used it, not even to cut bread. It lay wrapped in a cloth on the beam above his door, and when he died his eldest son found it there and did not know what it was.

They tell this in that country when someone prospers by hurting a neighbor and thinks that the dark has covered it. Something of it stays on you, they say. You may hide it under a long coat all your life. But you will know that it is there, and so will the dogs.

Pieces in the stacks are written under pen names. Personal pieces are composite accounts that gather experiences commonly described by therians and otherkin, and are offered as illustration, not as testimony about any one person. See the editorial principles.

Shelved under Stories Retold tales Werewolf lore

This page was last tended on .