From the essay shelf
Between Two Countries
On Sunday mornings I drive out to a boarding stable eleven miles from my apartment and lean on a fence. There are nine horses in the long field. They know my car. When I get out, two or three of them lift their heads and look at me, and then, having seen what I am, they put their heads down again and go on grazing.
What they have seen is a person. A fairly harmless one, who sometimes has carrots. They are right, of course. That is exactly what is standing at the fence. I have two legs and a rain jacket and I smell of soap and the inside of a car.
I have been a horse for as long as I can remember being anything. And every Sunday, for about a minute, it hurts in precisely the same place.
Neither one nor the other
People who write about being a therian tend to write about the animal: what it is like to feel the mane on a neck that has none, or the wrongness of hands. Those things are true for me too. But the part I have found hardest is not about my body at all. It is about company.
I work in an office with eleven people, and I like most of them. I am good at my job. I go to the farewell drinks. I can do all of it, and I have done it for years, and through all of it there is a pane of glass, very clean, between me and the room. They are doing something together that I am doing beside them. I have learned the steps. I do not hear the music. When they stand in a loose, noisy circle and talk across one another, I am the one a half step back, with my weight on one hip, watching the door.
That would be bearable if there were somewhere else. If I could finish work on a Friday and go home to the herd. But I have been to the fence, and I know what the horses see. I do not smell right. I do not move right. I cannot stand nose to tail with one of them under the hawthorn and switch the flies from her face while she switches them from mine, which is the most companionable thing I know of in the world and which I have never once done. If I climbed the fence and walked out among them, they would be polite, and wait to see whether I had brought anything.
So I belong to people, who do not feel like my kind, and I am shut out from horses, who do. I once read a wolf saying the same thing, more shortly than I can. He was not connected to humans, he said, because he was a wolf inside, and not connected to wolves, because he was in a human body. I remember the relief of reading it. I had thought that particular loneliness was mine alone.
What I tried
For some years I tried to settle the matter by choosing a side.
First I tried being wholly a person. I decided that the horse was a thing I had grown out of, and I stopped going anywhere near them. I joined things. I learned to stand in the circle with my weight on both feet. It lasted about two years, and at the end of it I was so tired that I could hardly lift my arms, and I had begun to dislike people I had no reason to dislike, simply for being so easily what I was working so hard to seem.
Then I went the other way. I spent every spare hour at stables. I mucked out stalls for nothing. I thought that if I could not be one of them, I could at least live among them, and that it would be nearly the same. It is not the same. I do not regret a day of it, and I learned more about horses in those two years than in the twenty before. But to be near a thing all day and to remain, in its eyes, the one who carries the bucket, is its own kind of loneliness, and a sharper one. A horse is not an idea. She is a large, particular animal with her own friendships, and I was not among them.
I say this because I think many of us try one or the other, and some of us try both, and I do not want anyone to think they failed. Neither country will take you whole. It is not because you did it badly.
The border
What changed things for me was a small remark. I had been writing, on and off, to a woman a good deal older than I am, a heron, who has lived with this for forty years. I wrote her a long and sorry letter about the fence. She wrote back four lines. The third was: "You keep describing the border as if it were a wall. It is a place. People live there."
I was annoyed for a week. Then I began to look at where I was actually standing.
I can do something that no horse can and that very few people can. I can stand at that fence and know, from the set of an ear at sixty yards, which mare is about to move the others off the good grass. I do not work it out. I simply see it, the way my colleagues see who is about to speak in a meeting. And then I can get into a car and drive home and write it down. I am not a failed horse, and I am not a failed person. I am something that stands where the two meet and can see a fair way into both.
That is not what I wanted. I wanted the hawthorn and the flies. But it is a real thing to be. And it has turned out to be habitable.
Other people on the border
It is habitable chiefly because it is not empty. This is the thing I would most like a lonely reader to take away.
The others who live here are not horses. I know one other horse, and we do not get on. The people I mean are a badger, a pair of crows, a lynx, a creature who says she is certain only that she has hooves, and the heron. On paper we have nothing in common. Our animals would eat one another, or run. We disagree about nearly everything, including what all of this is and where it comes from.
What we share is the fence. Every one of them knows what it is to stand in a room of pleasant people and feel the glass. Every one of them has, somewhere, a field or a wood or a stretch of sky that they look into and cannot enter. When I say, "I went to the stable on Sunday and it was a bad one," none of them asks me what I mean. The lynx says, "Ah," and after a moment tells me about a zoo she no longer visits.
It is the only country I have ever had full citizenship of, and it has no territory at all. It exists wherever two of us are talking. I did not find it at the fence. I found it by writing to a stranger and telling the truth, which is how these communities have always been found.
How I manage now
I have made a kind of peace with the two countries, as a person does who works in one town and loves another.
With people, I have stopped trying to pass through the glass and have started being a decent neighbor on my side of it. I stand a half step back, and I let myself. It turns out that a quiet, watchful person at the edge of a group is useful, and is often the one who notices that someone else is not all right. Two of my colleagues are something close to friends. They do not know what I am. They know that I am steady, and that I like to walk at lunchtime, and that is a true thing to know about a horse.
With horses, I go on Sundays and I lean on the fence. I have stopped asking them to recognize me. That was never fair. They owe me nothing, and I have come to think that looking at them without wanting anything is the nearest I can come to good manners in their country. Some Sundays it hurts and some it does not. When it does, I let it, for the minute it takes, and then I watch which mare moves the others off the grass.
And on Sunday evenings I write to the border.
I should say, because it would be dishonest not to, that there have been stretches when the loneliness was heavier than this account makes it sound, when it was not a minute at a fence but most of a winter. In one of those I went and talked to someone whose job it is to listen, and I am glad that I did. I did not go to be cured of horses. I went because I was sad for too long. She helped with the sadness, and the horse was neither here nor there to her, which is as it should be.
If you are standing at your own fence, whatever is on the far side of it, I cannot tell you that the gate will open. Mine has not. I can tell you that the place where you are standing has other people in it, a little way along, and that most of them would be glad of a letter.
Pieces in the stacks are written under pen names. Personal pieces are composite accounts that gather experiences commonly described by therians and otherkin, and are offered as illustration, not as testimony about any one person. See the editorial principles.